You spend hours crafting your monthly newsletter. You add committee updates, meeting summaries and event announcements. Then you check the stats: 10% open rate. Maybe 2% clicked anything. And rarely any replies.

Your newsletter isn’t being read: it’s being deleted faster than spam from a Nigerian prince. Why? Your members have trained themselves to ignore your emails. They see your association name in their inbox and think “more stuff I don’t care about” before hitting delete. You’ve become email noise, not email value.

The brutal part? You’re working hard on content that nobody wants. Meanwhile, associations with 40-50% open rates are driving engagement, renewals and real community connection through email. The difference isn’t luck. It’s understanding that newsletters aren’t about what you want to tell members: they’re about what members want to read.

Your Subject Lines Are Corporate Snoozefests

“Monthly Update” “Association Newsletter” “Important Information from Your Board.”

Congratulations, you’ve written subject lines that scream “delete me.” These subject lines fail because they tell members nothing about what’s inside or why they should care. They’re vague, predictable and generic.

So, what are subject lines that get opened?

“3 certifications that doubled members’ income in 2024” “The [Industry] change that affects your salary (starting next month)” “Why [Major Industry Player] just changed their policy (and what it means for you)”

Stop announcing that you sent a newsletter. Start promising value that makes people want to open immediately and watch your numbers skyrocket.

You’re Writing for the Board, Not Your Members

Most association newsletters read like meeting minutes: committee reports, governance updates, policy changes and organizational announcements that don’t move the needle, including:

• Governance policy updates

• Internal organizational changes

• Detailed board meeting summaries

• Committee formation announcements

• Generic “thank you to our volunteers” messages

Content people open emails for:

• Salary negotiation tips

• Career advancement strategies

• Job opportunities and career moves

• Practical skills they can use Monday morning

• Legislative changes impacting their profession

• Industry trend analysis that affects their work

Before including any content, ask “would a busy professional read this during their lunch break?” If not, cut it and create something new.

Nobody Cares About Your Events (Until You Make Them Care)

Half your newsletter is probably event announcements:

“Annual Conference Registration Now Open!” “Join Us for the Spring Networking Mixer!” “Save the Date for Our Upcoming Fall Workshop!”

These announcements fail because there’s nothing compelling. You’re listing logistics without explaining the actual value. Busy professionals don’t have spare time for generic networking events. They need compelling reasons to sacrifice their time.

Instead, sell outcomes, not logistics. What will they learn? Who will they meet? How will attending benefit their career? Answer those questions, then mention the date.

Your Newsletter Looks Like a Wall of Text (That Nobody Will Ever Read)

You write 1,200-word articles explaining complex industry topics in dense paragraphs. Maybe you bold a few headers. Then you wonder why engagement is terrible.

Reality check: Most members skim emails in 30 seconds or less. If your newsletter requires dedicated reading time, it’s getting deleted for “later” (which means never).

Format for actual human reading patterns:

Use short paragraphs: 2-3 sentences. White space is your friend.

Add compelling headers: Headers should work as standalone content.

Use bullet points: Easy to scan, easy to digest. Perfect for tips or useful takeaways.

Use bold strategically: Highlight key points, stats or action items. Don’t overdo it too much.

Add scroll-stopping visuals: Photos, graphics, or illustrations increase engagement.

You’re Sending Too Often (Or Not Often Enough)

Some associations send newsletters quarterly, then wonder why members forget they exist. Others send weekly, training members to ignore them because there’s always another one coming.

Too infrequent (quarterly): Members forget about your association between sends. No consistent engagement or relationship building.

Too frequent (weekly): You’re training members to ignore emails. Unless you’re a daily news source, weekly newsletters feel overwhelming.

The sweet spot: Bi-weekly or monthly, consistently. Enough frequency to stay relevant without becoming noise. Pick a schedule and stick to it religiously.

You Buried the Most Important Stuff at the Bottom

Most association newsletters follow the same structure: greeting, organizational updates, event announcements, industry news and a “stay connected” footer. You’re putting the dessert after members already left the table. Instead, here’s a content hierarchy that works:

Career value: Start with the most useful, relevant, valuable content. The thing members will care about and want to read.

Industry insights: Analysis, trends, or news that affects their work. Content that positions your association as essential.

Organizational updates: Put them at the end where they don’t kill engagement for people who don’t care about committee formations.

Most members won’t scroll to the bottom. Front-load the value or accept that nobody will see it.

Stop Creating Email Noise and Start Delivering Value

The difference between 10% open rates and 45% open rates isn’t some secret email marketing hack. It’s respecting your members’ time enough to send content they want to read. Every boring newsletter you send trains members to ignore future emails. Every valuable newsletter builds anticipation for the next one. You’re either building engagement or destroying it.

The good news? These are all fixable problems. The bad news? Fixing them requires time, strategy and expertise most associations don’t have while managing operations.

That’s where Slamdot comes in. We create email marketing strategies for associations that get opened, read and acted upon. The result: you engage members, improve retention, generate more leads and stay top of mind.

Want us to audit your newsletter and create a plan? Say hello!

See More Helpful Tips